There Is No New Thing Under the Sun

Rav Yitzchok Zilberstein relates:

תלמיד חכם אחד הגיע אל מורי חמי מרן הגרי”ש אלישיב שליט”א, וסיפר לו על עמודון ספרים עם פטנט חדש שיצא לשוק, שבו אפשר לסובב את הספרים כרצון איש ואיש, וכך לא יצטרך הלומד לקום ממקומו, אלא רק להושיט את היד ולסובב את העמודון ולהוציא את הספר.

מורי חמי לא היה מרוצה מכך. ‘ומה עם הספר חסידים הכותב שכאשר אדם קם ממקומו לחפש ספר בארון הספרים, יש בכך מצוה מיוחדת של עמל התורה’? – שאל.1

There exists prior art for this ‘patent’; this exact invention, as well as Rav Elyashiv’s precise objection to it, are found in the fifteenth century work לקט יושר, as discussed by Dan Rabinowitz:

“אותם הבחורים העשירים המפונקים שעשו להם שולחנות כשיושבין במקומן הופכין השולחן לאי זה צד שירצו ועליו הרבה ספרים לא טוב הם עושים, אדרבה כשמבקש אחר הספר ובא לו בטורח גודל זכור באותו מעשה מה שרוצה ללמוד, כמדומה לי שמצאתי לו סמך ב[יורה דעה] בסימן ג’ (שפח) ‘ולא כאלו שלומדין מתוך עידון’ וכו”

“Those rich, spoiled students that had made a revolving table which allowed for them to turn the table to get which ever book they wanted [without having to get up] such behavior is inappropriate. Instead, one who gets up to get a book and exerts themselves will remember that they had to look for the book [and will remember what the book said]. It seems to me [R. Yosef] that support for this position [that frowns upon the turntable] can be found in Yoreh Deah where it says “one should not study in luxury.'”

See Dan’s piece for further analysis and sources on the topic.

  1. רב יצחק זילברשטיין, עלינו לשבח, דברים (א) פרשת שופטים עמוד תסא []

https://www.digitaldirectinc.com/

https://www.dicksxxx.com/

https://www.devoswood.com/

https://www.designworks-ca.com/

https://www.dcs-dental.com/

https://www.dawncities.com/

https://www.davisonsign.com/

https://www.darkjonhendren.com/

https://www.dakwinds.com/

https://www.dakotabelle.com/

https://www.czechoslovakianbeads.com/

https://www.ctdispatch.com/

https://www.cseditors.com/

https://www.createmypump.com/

https://www.crcautoshop.com/

https://www.covernadirect.com/

https://www.corner-pocket.com/

https://www.coreografica.com/

https://www.cooperstownmotel.com/

https://www.convictsandcops.com/

https://www.conduitfest.com/

https://www.columbineint.com/

https://www.colorzenith.com/

https://www.cnitelecom.com/

https://www.clearcarecorp.com/

https://www.clanpi.com/

https://www.chrisvolkswagen.com/

https://www.chiron-rising.com/

https://www.chaminademo.com/

https://www.c-etc.com/

https://www.cescochemicals.com/

https://www.cdnwo.com/

https://www.ccc24k.com/

https://www.caveguias.com/

https://www.carltoyota.com/

https://www.carimar-inc.com/

https://www.caribewp.com/

https://www.carbonepasta.com/

https://www.carasys.com/

https://www.capefearnet.com/

https://www.camanrino.com/

https://www.cadientgroup.com/

https://www.cableco-op.com/

https://www.c21landmark.com/

https://www.bvulegal.com/

https://www.bussolabrasil.com/

https://www.bushhounds.com/

https://www.bubbaandsmoot.com/

https://www.brennekeschool.com/

https://www.bowhausdesign.com/

https://www.bolesfs.com/

https://www.bobandrewsmotors.com/

https://www.bmwsc.com/

https://www.bigboomver.com/

https://www.bh-records.com/

https://www.ben-wa.com/

https://www.beildhouse.com/

https://www.be422.com/

https://www.baysidewedding.com/

https://www.basketsbymaury.com/

https://www.bargains-mall.com/

https://www.baidu555.com/

https://www.babylontunaclub.com/

https://www.astro-psychic.com/

https://www.asicomm.com/

https://www.asg-jet.com/

https://www.asedf.com/

https://www.art4stuff.com/

https://www.arose4ever.com/

https://www.aquatics-direct.com/

https://www.aprovideo.com/

https://www.aprilfields.com/

https://www.apptechpoint.com/

https://www.animation-books.com/

https://www.anestat.com/

https://www.andypetreeracing.com/

https://www.andreaspage.com/

https://www.amt-net.com/

https://www.altitudetg.com/

https://www.alpha-g.com/

https://www.alphabeta-as.com/

https://www.allgadgetz.com/

https://www.alive7.com/

https://www.aizenpub.com/

https://www.airpartsonline.com/

https://www.aircraft-intl.com/

https://www.agenciafotoarte.com/

https://www.agd-exhibitions.com/

https://www.advaloremrealty.com/

https://www.adrija-ag.com/

https://www.addiesgifts.com/

https://www.abacus-engr.com/

https://www.69sexsites.com/

https://www.4websuccess.com/

https://www.4oliveus.com/

https://www.3mmg.com/

https://www.33comix.com/

https://www.3000inc.com/

https://www.1automata.com/

https://www.columbusasq801.com/

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

kubet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku bet

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku casino

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

ku11

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet88

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

kubet77

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku bet88

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku777

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711

ku711